The Google December 2025 Core Algorithm Update has begun its rollout, and like previous updates, it's causing shifts in search engine results. Understanding these changes is key to maintaining or improving your website's visibility. This post breaks down how to analyze the update's impact using real-world examples and tools like Ahrefs and Semrush.

Key Takeaways

• Analyze, Don't Panic: Core algorithm updates can cause traffic fluctuations. The best approach is to analyze what's happening rather than panicking.
• Monitor Rollout: Keep an eye on when the update finishes rolling out. This can take several weeks.
• Track Position History: Use tools like Ahrefs or Semrush to monitor keyword position history. This helps identify which sites are gaining or losing ground.
• Look for New Entrants: Websites that suddenly appear in the top results often reveal what Google is currently favoring.
• Content Depth Matters: Thin, generic content tends to suffer during updates, while in-depth, comprehensive content often performs better.
• Hub Pages Can Win: Round-up or hub pages that cover a topic broadly can be effective, especially for broad-intent searches.
• E-commerce Templates Gain Traction: In some cases, e-commerce category pages are outranking traditional articles, suggesting a shift towards product discovery.
• Reverse Engineering Success: Analyze winning pages to understand their structure, topical authority, and internal linking strategies. Then, apply these learnings to your own content.
• Internal Linking is Important: Strong internal linking helps distribute authority and can make pages more resilient during updates.

Understanding Algorithm Update Rollouts

Google's core algorithm updates don't happen instantly. They roll out over a period, sometimes taking weeks to complete. For instance, past updates have taken anywhere from 13 to 26 days. It's important to be aware of this rollout window, especially if you notice changes in your website's traffic. This period is the best time to analyze what's happening rather than making hasty changes.

Analyzing SERP Fluctuations with Position History

When an update rolls out, one of the most effective ways to understand its impact is by looking at keyword position history. Tools like Ahrefs and Semrush allow you to track how specific keywords perform over time. By examining the last 30 days, you can see which websites have entered or exited the top 10 results.

For example, when looking at the keyword "best running shoes," we might see sites like Reddit and YouTube appearing or remaining stable. We also look for sites that have dropped significantly, like Fleet Feet, which went from position three to position 10. Analyzing why this happened – perhaps a lack of topical authority or backlinks – can provide clues. Conversely, seeing a site like Adidas climb into the rankings, especially with a Shopify category page, suggests Google might be favoring e-commerce-style pages for certain queries.

Identifying Winning Content Patterns

Let's consider another example: the keyword "best television." Here, we might see Reddit at position five and YouTube at position nine. A particularly interesting case is CNET, which jumped from position 62 to position 8. Their page is a "roundup" or "hub page," covering the topic broadly. This highlights how Google might be favoring comprehensive hub pages for certain search intents.

If your website lacks such a hub page, this analysis provides a clear opportunity. Creating a dedicated hub page that links to more specific content on your site could help you regain lost positions. This reverse analysis of winning pages helps identify replicable factors like layout, topical authority, and internal linking strategies.

The Importance of Content Depth and Structure

When analyzing winning pages, a common theme emerges: depth and detail. For instance, comparing a thin article on "what is SEO" to the detailed content on Semrush or Yoast reveals a significant difference. The winning pages go into detail about various aspects of SEO, such as local SEO, website audits, and different types of SEO (e-commerce, local, video). They also often feature strong internal linking, pointing to dedicated pages for each sub-topic.

Conversely, thin content, which offers only a brief overview, is more likely to drop in rankings during core updates. This is because it lacks the conceptual breadth and semantic coverage that Google seems to prefer. If your content is thin, a rewrite aligned with the detailed, entity-rich patterns of competitors is likely necessary.

What to Do Next

After a core algorithm update, the key is to analyze and adapt. Use tools to track your keyword performance and identify which pages are affected. Look at the websites that are now ranking well and understand what they are doing differently. Are they using hub pages? Is their content more in-depth? Do they have a stronger internal linking structure?

By performing this kind of reverse analysis, you can identify winning factors and apply them to your own website. Whether it's rewriting thin content, creating new hub pages, or improving your internal linking, taking a data-driven approach will help you navigate these algorithm shifts successfully.

‍